Seeing Dots

February 17, 2012 § 2 Comments

I was perusing the collections from New York Fashion Week (read: perving on Proenza Schouler) when I started to think about the idea of cultural appropriation. Basically, is it ok to draw a direct reference from a culture not your own. It’s very much a grey area, and open to interpretation. In my own work I’ve been inspired by the cultures I grew up surrounded by in South Africa and Hong Kong, a cultural inheritance that is not necessarily mine, although it definitely had a formative impact in shaping who I am, as well as my design sensibility.

But then I have always used other cultures as a reference, interpreting them from my own point of view. So maybe more recontextualising what I see rather than ripping it off. It seems insensitive (and somewhat colonialist) to just take someone’s cultural heritage and do with it what you will.

What sparked off this train of thought was the new Rodarte collection. Inspired by the Australian Outback, it was awash with references to the dusty plains of the outback, aboriginal prints, and the hardworking “Aussie” spirit.

Clearly Laura and Kate Mulleavy (the duo behind Rodarte) have never been to Australia.

I’ve always really liked Rodarte, their collections always trod a fine line between crazy and wearable, and carried a fine art sensibility (though their last Van Gogh inspired collection also seemed a bit flat). This time the dresses were frumpy, and the colour’s had no impact. As Suzy Menkes put it in her review for the International Herald Tribune, “where was the underlying tension, the horror movie sex-and-gore that the sisters brought to earlier collections? For all the exceptional handwork creating a slim shearling dress or chunky cable knits, the show lacked vigour.”

Though apart from the general blah-ness of this collection, and the fairly lame, cliched image of Australia it portrayed, it was the use of Aboriginal dot painting in some of the prints that I found most disappointing. Especially considering under Australian Indigenous Culture and Intellectual Property Laws the use of these patterns is highly regulated. And it’s just not ok. Be inspired by it by all means, but don’t splash it all over some (very pricey) dresses, unless you’re planning on maybe compensating the people you were “inspired by” in the first place.

But have a look for yourself, perhaps I’m being overly sensitive. And as I pointed out, everyone is influenced by what they see, including myself. But in all fairness the indigenous people, both in Australia and across the rest of the world, have dealt with enough without seeing their cultural heritage trickle down from high fashion runway’s to the racks of Urban Outfitters or Zara.

And for the record, Proenza Schouler killed it. Again.

Advertisements

Tagged: , , , , ,

§ 2 Responses to Seeing Dots

  • Ella says:

    I totally agree that these prints are culturally inappropriate in the sense that the designs have been too directly ripped from Aboriginal art. However, I wonder what makes them different from Shaun Samson’s designs that you posted previously. They are pretty much ripping off traditional Mexican fabric patterns. Do you think that Aboriginal designs are more sacred for some reason, or do they just seem more sacred because it’s Australian and more relevant to us?

    Also, If you are not already familiar with it, I think you would be interested in the artwork of Lucas Grogan: http://www.lucasgrogan.com/
    I think most people find it visually appealing work, however what is even more fascinating is the commentary surrounding it. Check out the comments on one of his previous exhibitions on his website: http://www.lucasgrogan.com/portfolio/tell-im-hes-dreamin/

    P.S. Love your blog 🙂

    • unjhewitt says:

      I guess the Shaun Samson prints seem more abstracted, and less obvious (but then this is definitely an area where objectivity comes into play, so it’s really each to their own). And then there is the fact that the Aboriginal dot prints do have a stronger spiritual association, not that I’m saying the Mexican patterns don’t, I may have to do some research into that.

      The Lucas Grogan stuff is cool, Thanks for that!

      And I’m glad you like my blog!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Seeing Dots at untheprefix.

meta

%d bloggers like this: